When programming, I often find myself striving for minimalism. Trying to make the program as succinct as possible, sweating over details like how to arrange the sections in a file, or the number of files to create.
But minimalism in programming may cause programs to appear cramped, may persuade you to choose forms of expression that are unneededly terse, and may also lead to programs that are hard to refactor or extend.
Point is, when you start programming, you don't know how big the program's gonna be, so starting with minimalism may be a bad choice. When looking at the sources of some huge programs, I found that some of them have found very relaxed ways to deal with their sprawling size. Gnus for example comprises dozens of large source files, containing hundreds or thousands of operational definitions, and yet remains very readable.
I don't want to get into the details of architecting large programs - I'd rather like to focus on a way to write programs, from the start, so that the source then has a "density" that's adequate to its size. Gnus for example is meandering, and that's perfectly adequate - Gnus being a mail reader for the most customizable OS in existence. That's a job that's never done, so the source should reflect that - you can't write a cute blog post about a program like Gnus, there's no single overarching, minimalist design principle.
Maybe, as Perlis said, every program needs to be written at least twice. After the first run, we know the approximate size of the program, and can then find a code density/terseness that's adequate to that size.
I find minimalism in source code is often limiting. In my next program, I'll write it from the start as if it were really huge.
Manuel Simoni's blog about programming (languages).
Wow - simple idea, with mind bending results. People i think - and as they should in some cases - get a nice kick out of making programs code in to as few lines as possible.
ReplyDeleteThat's a good academic feat, but it's a terrible way to make programs.
I'm creating a browser based multiplayer game based on Node.js - and im finding that to be a very annoying convention in javascript. To inline everything as if it makes you more of a real programer that you used 4 lines instead of 10.